Thursday, May 21, 2009

Prosecutors Justify (?) Blocking DNA Testing for Prisoners

This interesting (appalling?) article in the New York Times earlier this week regarding a movement to not allow DNA testing for inmates claiming innocence:
Louisiana, where Mr. Reed is in prison, is one of 46 states that have passed laws to enable inmates like him to get such a test. But in many jurisdictions, prosecutors are using new arguments to get around the intent of those laws, particularly in cases with multiple defendants, when it is not clear how many DNA profiles will be found in a sample.

The laws were enacted after DNA evidence exonerated a first wave of prisoners in the early 1990s, when law enforcement authorities strongly resisted reopening old cases. Continued resistance by prosecutors is causing years of delay and, in some cases, eliminating the chance to try other suspects because the statute of limitations has passed by the time the test is granted.


For an interesting and thoughtful analysis of this topic, see this post from Grits for Breakfast.

No comments: