Monday, December 21, 2009
Important Case on Prosecutor Immunity for Procuring False Testimony
The case presents interesting issues on the pitfalls of using informants and whether there should be some responsibility put on the police and prosecutors who use them.
Saturday, December 19, 2009
Criminal Profiling Part One
Some time ago when my children where young they, like all other children, worried about Monsters. I did the obligatory "under the bed check" and I even had a "magic flashlight which "poofed" monsters. At that time I had been immersed in the study of serial murders and forensic science for several years and dearly wish the magic flashlight existed.
One of the middle children was extremely independent and tended to wander off with her younger brother in pursuit. There were several episodes where I found myself running frantically through my neighborhood in tears searching for the two youngest. I eventually found them playing at a stone bridge near our house. In an attempt to prevent them from wandering off to play at the bridge I told them a monster lived under the bridge. The only thing that could protect them was me. They both remember this story and the youngest still asks if there really was a monster under the bridge. "There could have been." I think to myself. I say "no I just told you that so you would not come down here to play by yourself." I will have to tell him about the real monsters soon.
All mothers and most parents in general know the feeling of panic when your child disappears even briefly. None ever wish to endure this feeling for more than a few minutes. I cannot imagine the torture for parents who have to endure it for months or years. The subject of the next few articles will be criminal profiling. In particular, profiling of serial killers who prey on there victims for sexual or psychological pleasure.
A serial killer is defined as someone who kills and then has a cooling off period followed by one or more subsequent murders. This would include psycho/sexual murderers, hired assassins, many political leaders and so on. For this series of articles we will look at those "lone wolf" killers who seem to be motivated by sexual or psychological gratification.
This instinctive fear that someone has spirited away our child is not new. It is reflected in literature such as Grim's fairy tales and other children's stories which warn of the dangers of wandering to far from home or speaking to strangers. These stories exist in almost every culture and are directed at children and young women as there audience. Stories such as Bluebeard and the Dracula legend also indicate that serial murder may not be purely a modern phenomenon. Both of these stories are based on historical figures who were serial killers.
In past many people were born and lived there whole lives in the same village. Strangers were easily identifiable and probably treated with some caution. In modern times, the rise of large cities affords the individual a certain degree of anonymity. Virtually most of the people you will see in any public place will be strangers. This situation heightens the sense of fear and the possibility that somewhere in that crowd is lurking a killer. The problem is you can't tell by looking at them or even talking to them. The expression "a wolf in sheep's clothing" applies aptly to our modern problem with serial murderers in that they can hide in the crowd undetected until it is too late.
The dangers for children and young women are not as new as some writers believe. Many such as Dr. Elliot Leyton author of Hunting Humans and Men of Blood see serial murder as having increased dramatically over the last century particularly in the United States. Leyton believes that the rise of the modern serial killer is a cultural phenomenon. Others like John Douglas and Mark Olshaker, both founders of the F.B.I. behavioral science unit, believe that it is a phenomenon which has existed for quite a long period but was not recognized as a unique form of criminal behavior(Douglas and Olshaker, 1991).
Throughout time and various cultures mankind has been a hunter. The genetic selection would have been in favor of those men will strong hunting skills and instincts. A man with strong hunting skills is better able to provide for his offspring and they tend to survive in larger numbers than children who are deprived of food. The hunter's genes are passed on to the next generation and so on down through time. Those instincts are still present in modern humans. Some become soldiers or police officers where the hunt is modified by cars and "capture only" rules apply but it is still a hunt. A wolf pack will chase its prey until it is exhausted and then herd it into an inescapable area for the "take down". During a police chase, of any kind, the same thing occurs.
Others join sports which satisfy the hunting instincts. Unfortunately for us the rise of the modern large city has deprived some of us of the ability to satisfy the instinct to hunt. At some point in their lives-usually early- serial killers loose the ability to control the instinct to hunt.
Animals used in experiments which test overcrowding will kill each other and exhibit inappropriate sexual behavior in response to stress (Leyton, 1986). Whether the inability to control this instinct is triggered by cultural factors are physical and mental abuse I am not sure. It could be either in combination with a genetic predisposition for a strong hunting instinct. Since serial killers come from all different backgrounds I suspect it is sometimes one or both which trigger the inability to control the hunting instinct.
In some killers the kill is linked to sexual pleasure and is more likely a product of similar abuse experienced by the killer. Some seem to enjoy the game of "catch me if you can" and the notoriety it brings. Others are truly mentally unable to judge right for wrong. I will discuss the motives for murder a little later in this series.
There are probably hundreds of ways to make a chocolate cake each using standard ingredients in varying amounts. A person can not point to "flour" and say "that is what will result in a chocolate cake if I bake it." The cake is a combination of many ingredients. The amounts of each ingredient used determine the type of chocolate cake. So it is with serial killers. They are not created by one action or factor but by a mix of genetics, cultural encouragement of violence, physical and mental stress factors such as abuse and childhood linking of sexual pleasure with pain, violence or fear.
Full article can be found here.
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
Civil Liabilities Associated With False Confessions
Fox v. Will County: Fox was interrogated as a suspect in his daughter's murder and confessed. DNA later eliminated Fox as a suspect, therefore proving the confession to be false. During the civil suit, Fox claimed that his request for an attorney was ignored, that the investigator engaged in illegal interrogation tactics, including threats of harm and offering promises of leniency. The investigator denied engaging in these illegal tactics but, since the interrogation was not electronically recorded, there was no evidence to support his testimony. The jury found for the plaintiff and awarded Fox 15.5 million dollars. (The case is currently being appealed.)
Washington v. Virginia State Police: A mentally retarded suspect named Earl Washington confessed to rape and murder, was convicted and sentenced to death. While on death row he was exonerated through DNA and freed from prison. Washington's confession contained a number of crime details only the guilty person should have known. Partially because of this, the plaintiff argued that the interrogation was improperly conducted because the investigator must have provided Washington with these crime details. The jury awarded Washington 2.5 million dollars.
These cases are familiar to us because we testified at both trials - not on behalf of the law enforcement agency, but for the plaintiff who had filed the lawsuit. Furthermore, these are not isolated incidents. We are aware of several other ongoing lawsuits involving a known false confession obtained through alleged improper interrogation techniques. Over the last 20 years we have written about other successful lawsuits alleging illegal interrogation techniques, generally involving violation of a suspect's constitutional rights (interrogating after Miranda rights were invoked, failure to stop an interrogation after the suspect asked for an attorney, etc.)
Civil suits that are focused on the conduct of the investigators have been successful for two basic reasons. First, the plaintiff clearly suffered damages (a verified false confession contributed to a conviction and wrongful incarceration). Second, the investigator utilized interrogation techniques that were clearly illegal or known to increase the risk of a false confession. The illegal interrogation techniques cited are not minor infractions or obscure legal procedures. They address fundamental and well-established legal precedence that have applied to interrogations for many years.
These civil suits should serve as a wake-up call to law enforcement and government agencies to ask the question, "Are our investigators conducting legal interrogations?" The following is an overview of legal guidelines for conducting interrogations. If these basic procedures are not followed, the agency may be at risk for false confessions that could lead to a civil suit.
Suspects at Higher Risk for False Confessions (Additional caution must be exercised when interrogating these suspects)
Juveniles (suspects under the age of 15 especially when they have had little exposure to the criminal justice system)
Low Intelligence (A suspect with an IQ below 65 e.g., a 20-year-old suspect functioning at the level of a 13-year-old)
Mentally Impaired (Thought or perceptual disorders, severe depression or anxiety disorders)
Miranda Rights (The waiver must be knowing and voluntary)
The suspect must be truthfully advised of the issue under investigation
The suspect should not be significantly impaired as a result of alcohol or drugs
For suspects with lower intelligence or suspects who have a language barrier, document the suspect's understanding of each right by asking, "What does that mean to you?"
Coercion (A confession must be obtained in the absence of physical force)
The suspect cannot be subjected to physical pain or discomfort, e.g., slapped, punched, shaken, bright lights, extremely high or low temperatures, etc.
Compulsion (Specifically threatening the suspect with adverse consequences if he does not confess)
Threatening the suspect with physical harm
- Threatening to place the suspect's children in foster care
- Threatening to charge the suspect with a more serious crime
- Threatening to discontinue public aid, deport suspect, etc.
Duress (Potentially creating an unbearable environment where the suspect's only escape is to confess.)
Interrogations lasting longer than four hours if the suspect is still maintaining his innocence.
- Multiple interrogators conducting the interrogation, especially as a tag team.
- Depriving the suspect of sleep, food, medications
Trickery and Deceit (The investigator's use of trickery and deceit cannot shock the conscience of the court or community)
The investigator cannot give the suspect false legal advice, "This is your last chance to tell the truth."
The investigator cannot create evidence against the suspect e.g., type up a fictitious crime lab report indicating the suspect's DNA was found at the crime scene.
Faulty Memory (A coerced-internalized confession occurs when the investigator convinces an innocent person that he must be guilty of committing a crime)
When interrogating a suspect who claims to have memory loss during the period of the crime (intoxication, amnesia, head trauma, etc.) the investigator:
- Should not try to convince the suspect that he committed the crime
- Should not lie to the suspect about having incriminating evidence
- Should make certain the suspect's confession contains valid corroboration
Corroboration
Dependent: Information purposefully withheld from the suspect and the public. This is information only the guilty suspect should know and it is obviously improper to reveal dependent corroboration to a suspect during an interrogation.
Independent: Information not known until the confession that is later verified as true by the investigator. Once this information is learned it needs to be confirmed as true. If it does not check out, there may be a problem with the confession.
Credit and Permission Statement: This Investigator Tip was developed by John E. Reid and Associates Inc. Permission is hereby granted to those who wish to share or copy the article. For additional 'tips' visit www.reid.com; select 'Educational Information' and 'Investigator Tip'. Inquiries regarding Investigator Tips should be directed to Janet Finnerty johnreid@htc.net. For more information regarding Reid seminars and training products, contact John E. Reid and Associates, Inc. at 800-255-5747 or www.reid.com.
Tuesday, December 15, 2009
Supreme Court to Take Texting Case, LOL

The Supreme Court accepted review on CITY OF ONTARIO V. QUON. The issue involves whether the City of Ontario police department violated the constitutional privacy rights of an employee when it inspected personal text messages sent and received on a government pager. A little background is useful...
The City of Ontario had issued two-way pagers to its SWAT team. The officers were told they were responsible for charges in excess of 25,000 characters a month. The City had a formal policy reserving the right to monitor “network activity including e-mail and Internet use,” allowing “light personal communications” by employees but cautioning that they “should have no expectation of privacy.” It did not directly address text messages.
Under an informal policy adopted by a police lieutenant, those who paid the excess charges themselves would not have their messages inspected. The lieutenant eventually changed his mind and ordered transcripts of messages sent and received by Sgt. Quon. In one month in 2002, only 57 of more than 450 of those messages were related to official business. Many of the messages were sexually explicit in nature.
Sergeant Quon and some of the people with whom he messaged sued, saying their Fourth Amendment rights had been violated. The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit said the department’s formal policy had been overridden by the “operational reality” of the lieutenant’s informal policy. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the Fourth Amendment protects the contents of the text messages even if the address (in this case the telephone number) is not protected. See Ninth Circuit Blog for analysis of the Ninth Circuit opinion.
Now, the Supreme Court will decide whether the officers had a reasonable expectation of privacy with the work-issued pager; whether the police department could have found a less intrusive way to review the messages; and whether the individuals who sent the messages to a police-issued pager have a reasonable expectation of privacy that the message would be free from review by the employer. The case has large ramifications for anyone interested in the Fourth Amendment and privacy issues. Many businesses, incjavascript:void(0)luding government employers, issue cell phones, pagers, and computers to their employees so the holding could affect many people. For more coverage of this issue, see the New York Times article and the Scotus Blog.
Friday, December 11, 2009
Thursday, December 10, 2009
Tuesday, December 8, 2009
National Museum of Crime and Punishment Crime Library
Saturday, December 5, 2009
WACDL HOLIDAY AUCTION A SUCCESS

The Washington Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers held their annual CLE and holiday party tonite to toast another year of civil liberties won and lost and rededicate to our mission for 2010. Auction highlights included the "Tree of Liberty" Holiday Tree with handmade criminal defense themed ornaments generously donated by one WACDL member and later bid on by another member, a prominent Seattle criminal defense attorney. Thanks very much for the generous support for a great criminal defense association and toast the year to come.
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
Where to find Opinions from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
Friday, November 27, 2009
Wednesday, November 25, 2009
Decomposition of Baby Pigs
The technique of time-lapse photography is employed to illustrate the rapid removal of carrion (4 days reduced to approximately 6 minutes). The film demonstrates the sequence of tissue destruction and the role of insects in the ultimate dismemberment of the pig carcass and soil movement. The pink and purple beads were added to show the intense activities of the insects in moving the carcass and soil.
Payne writes..."My study was the first "detailed" study of succession in animal decomposition and the first with the pig as the model. The significance of the pig is that it closely approximates the human body (skin, body hair, size etc.) so the data generated could be used in modern forensic science to approximate the time of human deaths. At that time it was simply not possibly (moral/ethical/legal concerns) to perform decompositon studies with human corpses, I know because I tried and was denied. Even so there were many instances where some concerned person buried my research pigs."
The pigs used in the experiment were dead when Jerry Payne picked them up from local farmers. Mama pigs (sows) often lay down on their tiny piglets and crush them. This was very common on small farms and led to the invention and deployment of farrowing pens(birthing pens) where the sow is contained and the piglets have a heated space where they are not in danger of being crushed.
Flies have four life stages: adult (the fly), egg, larva (the maggot) and pupa. Maggots crawl into dark, secluded places to pupate (the stage where they undergo the transformation from maggot to adult). Since the maggots are white or cream colored they are easily seen and taken by predators. Going undergroundand away from the carcass offers protection from uv light and predators and allows them seclusion to pupate. This pupal stage is immobile. Maggots don't have to burrow into the soil as they could easily conceal themselves in leaf litter or any decayed organic material.
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Shoulder Surfing
Due to a job requiring extensive travel or simply due to a lack of office space, many companies can chose to have an individual perform their work while away on a business trip or at home. Connecting to work from an off-site location by way of 'remote access' is fairly common these days. All the employee needs to connect up to his/her home office is a computer with a modem, the proper telephone number or website to access the company's system/network, a user name and a password [5]. To an employee, off-site access may be an extremely convenient tool. However, if information about how to access a company's system/network is in plain view on an employee's computer system, this can be extremely dangerous. To a shoulder surfer glancing by, this information can be very valuable if this particular attacker wanted to gain access to information about that company.
At your place of employment you might even be at risk. Co-workers might be curious as to the activities you engage in on your computer. If their jobs require that they do different tasks then you, they may want to learn how you do your job. They may want to look at the programs you utilize to perform your job. Even worse, they may want to check your e-mail accounts. These are all possible motives of the shoulder surfer who may just be around the corner in the next cubicle.